His eyes raked over her ugly powder blue prom gown, mentally undressing her.

Everyone is talking about the twilight series by Stephanie Meyer, so I went out and bought the first one.

I read it yesterday…

um. WOW. Stunningly lame. I keep trying to figure out how to explain it. I accidentally took a 25 minute shower this morning because I was trying to arrange the words badly written, soft core, porn, teenagers, stilted, vampires and nothing new under the sun, all into one sentence.

I cant fucking stand when I read a book and I can picture the authors ‘list of character traits’ written on a piece of paper tacked to her peg board above her desk. Helloooo one dimensional!

The dialog was so utterly painful I had to stop and count to ten every other minute.  The boy character was creepy and just not interesting, the girl character I had hope for in the beginning. But then she remained one dimensional and the weird-ass creepy power dynamics really kicked in and she became all helpless and fucking whiny, constantly whining about how ‘perfect’ the boy was and could do everything ‘perfectly’ while she was hanging around with the words ‘accident prone’ written next to her name.

Tgheir whole shtick with interactions consist of him smirking and her squinting or the more poetic phrase – she narrowed her eyes at him. whatevers!GOD! and the whole creepy thing about her smell. EW! Could we make her more of an object? There was NOTHING romantic about this book. AT ALL.

The book reminded me of two things, the Eragon books by christopher paolini and a fairy tale I had to write in 3rd grade that I titled ‘The Orange Juice of Life’.  For that fairy tale assignment we had to write an original fairy tale. Now, by third grade I had read all the actual grimm’s fairy tales (not the jerky watered down ones) and all of Hans Christian Anderson which we all know are super creepy and weird and totally undisney-esque. But anyway, I felt like an ass because I couldn’t fucking think of anything to write! So I basically copied a Grimm’s fairy tale and substituted ‘orange juice’ for ‘water’. Actually I panicked and put absolutely no actual thought into it (story of my life) and that’s what I picture happened to Ms.  (heiress to the great lemon estate?) Meyer . I don’t know if you’ve read the Eragon books, but they are pretty bad. But he wrote that first one when he was FIFTEEN. I mean, the story isn’t all bad but the dialog is heinous  and you can tell he was sort of trying to be original but ended up doing the orange juice of life thing pretty often. Ms Meyer is a grown woman however and having her book compared to Eragon is meant to hurt.

You might say, oh yeah? well everyone loves her book and so she is making crap loads of money and is successful, SO THERE!”

Oh yeah? People say the same thing about Madonna but she’s still a cunty bitch who can barely sing.

I thought this book was trashy, badly written and unoriginal. It could have been good (maybe) if it had been cut down to about 150 pages and sold only in Transylvania (and washington) gift shops.

Somewhere in the middle of the book I thought, ‘how an I going to read the rest of these books without my brain exploding?’

Does anyone want the first twilight book?! I will totally send it to you and you can write an answering post about how great it really is. Leave a comment!

No related posts.

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.


  1. That was an awesome book review.

    I hate books like that. Which is why I take recommendations from only a very select group of people.

  2. zombiegrrrl

    hmm. now that makes me want to read it just to see how bad it is. everything else I’ve heard says oh how it’s sooooo good but looked to me just as you describe. how long is it?

  3. mct

    Glad to hear this. Read a review of the Twilight scene in Time magazine and it sounded a bit goofy. Seemed like a bunch of Dark Hearts who loved the ugly, fake youth of The Hills, and were super pleased to have it mixed in with the Undying Gravitas of Anne Rice (before she jumped the Vampire Shark)

    I saw the poster for the movie, though, and the kids looked pale and brooding and drawn, so it’ll probably do well (bleh).

  4. I think that was the best book review I ever read. I’m so proud to be your sister…

  5. I actually enjoyed the forst two – to a point. I think they had potential, but I got so sick of the angst and drama and “romantic” stalker-ish stuff. The third wasn’t as good and the fourth was predictable and disappointing. And the movie looks like ass.

    As for Eragon – I liked those a bit more, though I think some of it was my love for that genre, plus my amazement over a young boy writing it. Of course, once I start reading a series, I have a hard time stopping, so I will most likely buy the next one when it comes out in September. And the movie WAS ass.

  6. OK, Rum + typing = “forst”

  7. I also totally liked the Eragon books but they were still kinda bad… I’m looking forward to the new one that comes out in late August!
    I may have to read the rest of the twilight ones too, I guess. I’ll get them from the library though.

  8. I am weeping with laughter. WEEPING. I had to dab tears. I had to take a little break after the “Oh yeah?” part, because I was starting to breathe hitchily.

  9. This isn’t even remotely like any of the books I usually read and I admit to seeing way too many blogs gushing about it. It might be worth to read to see how horrible it is!

  10. I just posted a review for james Patterson’s new book “Dangerous Days of Daniel X.” I couldn’t stand it. Authors who think they’re doing kids a favor by writing books are just wrong. Authors who write good books because they are good writers? They’re awesome. I listed some good ones in my review.

  11. right on- they’re terrible and it’s painful to meet a kid that’s so into them. Worse, though, are the adult women I know who are so into them. And think they are well written.
    AGH!

  12. I am so glad that you posted this review because I had actually been toying with buying that book today at Target. What’s with all the bloggers raving about it? I completely trust you and I thank you for saving me money and precious time!

  13. I keep thinking to myself ‘cheesy vampire books can be fun to read…’ but that series just sounds atrocious to me. You’re the first person I’ve heard confirm my suspicion — I just knew it was soft-core mediocrity.




Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>